Find the best boat rentals in Fishers Island
Top Fishers Island Boat Rentals and Yacht Charters
$258+
/hour
Westbrook, CT
A Long Island Sound Sailing Experience!
$1,050+
/hour
Montauk, NY
Gran Turismo Sag Harbor/Gurneys Montauk Yacht Club
$617+
/hour
Montauk, NY
All new Van Dutch Sport 40, only one in the world produced!
Sag Harbor, NY
2025 29' Axopar Sun Top Brand New Sag Harbor, New York
$1,125+
/hour
East Hampton, NY
Beautiful Riva Yacht Perfect for Hamptons
Sag Harbor, NY
32' 2020 Sundancer + Seabob Yacht Charter in Sag Harbor, New York
East Hampton, NY
36' 2021 Aquila Catamaran + Seabob Yacht Rental in East Hampton, NY
Sag Harbor, NY
23' Four Winns Boat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
62' Pershing + 3 Seabobs Yacht Charter in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
29' 2023 Sea Ray SDX Boat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
East Hampton, NY
50' Azimut Atlantis + Seabob Yacht Charter in East Hampton, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
27' 2025 Lilybaeum Powerboat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
29' 2021 Yacht Hampton Escape Boat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
26' 2023 Mastercraft-Watersports Boat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
43' 2021 Pardo + Seabob Yacht Charter in Sag Harbor, New York
Sag Harbor, NY
29' 2025 De Antonio + Seabob Boat Rental in Sag Harbor, New York
Montauk, NY
Boca Raton's newest & classiest luxe yacht with seabob & floating mat
Montauk, NY
36' 2023 Aquila Catamaran + Seabob Boat Rental in Montauk, New York
How to rent a boat in Fishers Island?
Find the perfect boat
Enter your desired location and date to explore our fleet of boats.
Select a captain
Choose to drive yourself or select a USCG licensed captain.
Book with ease
Connect with your boat owner and complete your booking online.
Set sail
Enjoy your day on the water with friends and family!
Why Boatsetter?
As the global leader in peer-to-peer boat rentals, Boatsetter offers an easy, safe and accessible way to experience on-the-water adventure. With boat rentals in 600+ locations, finding a boat is easy and with the option to tap into the largest network of USCG licensed captains, boating experience is not required.
Featured in
Got questions?
Frequently asked questions
What makes Boatsetter different from other boat rental platforms?
What makes Boatsetter different is peace of mind. Boatsetter is the first and only boat rental marketplace to offer insurance on every peer-to-peer boat rental. We know choosing the right boat rental platform is essential to your experience while on the water. That's why we've gone the extra mile to focus on safety through our exclusive partnership with GEICO Marine and BoatUS. As the first and only boat rental marketplace to offer insurance on every peer-to-peer rental, you are protected during all rentals with insurance coverage and on-water assistance through TowBoatUS.
How to rent a boat on Boatsetter?
At Boatsetter, our mission is to make getting out on the water as easy as possible. With our intuitive booking system, you can rent a boat as soon as today.
-First, you must determine your budget and the type of boat you want to rent.
-Next, decide where you would like to boat and the kind of boat you would like to spend the day on.
-Finally, determine if you will be needing a boat captain and reach out to the boat owner.
That’s it! You’re officially on your way to a fantastic day out on the water.
How much does it cost to rent a boat?
The cost to rent a boat depends on whether you are renting for a half-day or a full day, the boat features and the boat size can impact your boat rental price. Rental prices can range from $200 to $1,000 plus depending on the boat rental itself and the length of time of the rental.
How many people can fit on the boat rental?
The number of people who can fit on boat rental largely depends on the boat’s size and how many life jackets are on board. Currently the coast guard allows a maximum of 10-12 people on a Boatsetter boat rental.
How much does it cost to rent a yacht?
The cost of renting a yacht depends on the boat’s size and the amount of time you’ll use the yacht. The onboard amenities and luxurious accommodations also dictate the price. You can contact our yacht specialists for a custom quote by visiting https://www.boatsetter.com/luxury-yacht-charters.
How old do you have to be to rent a boat?
You must be 18 years old to rent a captained boat and 25 years old if you would like to rent a bareboat charter.
Do I need a boating license to rent a boat?
Boating license requirements vary from state to state. As a renter, you are responsible for understanding local state requirements.
Can you rent a yacht for the day?
Boatsetter allows you to rent a yacht for the day. Single-day yacht rentals are available for a select number of yachts. To chat with a yacht specialist please visit https://www.boatsetter.com/luxury-yacht-charters.
Can you rent a yacht for the week?
Boatsetter allows its customers to rent a yacht for the week. Renting a yacht for a week gives you more access to the wide range of yachts available on our platform. You can either book a rental directly through the site or connect with one of our charter specialists to plan your trip here: https://www.boatsetter.com/luxury-yacht-charters.
Can you rent a yacht for the month?
Booking a month-long yacht rental is a detailed and hands-off process when working with our team of yacht charter specialists. We tailor each yacht charter to our client's specific wants and needs. Our luxury yacht charter specialists can be reached at (954) 715-4114 or by visiting https://www.boatsetter.com/luxury-yacht-charters.
How to rent a private yacht?
Renting a private yacht is a very detailed experience that caters to your exact needs while onboard one of our luxury yachts. To plan your private yacht rentals experience please visit https://www.boatsetter.com/luxury-yacht-charters.
How much does it cost to rent a pontoon boat?
The cost of renting a pontoon boat depends on the size, location, and rental time of the boat. Prices can range anywhere from $200 for a half-day rental or just under a $1,000 for longer rentals.
How much does it cost to charter a yacht?
The cost to charter a yacht varies depending on the boat size and the length of the charter. Prices typically range from less than $1,000 to $5,000 plus if you’re wanting to charter the yacht overnight.
How much does it cost to rent a boat for the day?
The cost of renting a boat for the day on average ranges from $200 to $1200. The cost to rent a boat varies depending on the size of the boat and the length of time that you will be using the boat.
How does the boat insurance work?
Boat insurance typically covers loss caused by things such as fire, sinking, storms, and collisions. The extent of the coverage varies depending on the policy.
Do I need my own insurance to rent a boat?
You do not need boat insurance when renting with Boatsetter. Coverage is provided under the Peer-to-Peer Boat Rental Policy, which is underwritten by GEICO Marine Insurance Company. The policy was written from the ground up as a stand-alone recreational boat rental insurance policy covering the period of time that the boat is being rented and is available for all non-commercially insured boats.
Does Boatsetter screen renters?
Yes. We use a system called Cognito to ensure that payment information matches the renter's identity. We also require renters taking out a captained boat to be at least 18 years old and on a bareboat to be at least 25 years old.
Is listing my boat on Boatsetter free?
Yes! Listing a boat is completely free. We only take a commission when your boat is rented. We only make money when you do!
What if I'm not comfortable having a renter drive my boat?
If you are not comfortable having a renter drive your boat, we have an expansive network of licensed and experienced captains. Once your boat is listed, you can filter through our network of captains and favorite captains in your area that you would like to operate your boat.
Top destinations for boat rentals
Top boat rentals reviews in Fishers Island, NY
-
5/5 stars
Ryan
Jul 2024 -
5/5 stars
Such an amazing time! Joy is so friendly and accommodating, Scupper is top captain!
Rosana
Jul 2024 -
5/5 stars
-
5/5 stars
Great day…. Crew were beyond accommodating to us. All my guests still talking about the day….
Scott
Aug 2023 -
5/5 stars
-
5/5 stars
Fantastic boat and crew. Highly recommend
Kearnon
Aug 2023 -
5/5 stars
Great day.. Dave the captain very pleasant and accommodating.
Scott
Jul 2023 -
5/5 stars
-
5/5 stars
My son had a wonderful time. Staff were very pleasant
Nickey
Aug 2022 -
5/5 stars
Bud
Aug 2022 -
5/5 stars
Joy was an amazing captain. Awesome sailboat, nice experience. Highly recommend!!
Eric
Aug 2022 -
5/5 stars
Best captain and crew! Couldnt reccomend this rental more to anyone else.
Christopher
Jul 2022
Own a boat?
Boatsetter lets you make money renting out your boat. Peace of mind and insurance is included in every rental, and you choose who rents your boat.
List Your BoatReady to set sail?
Search and find the perfect boat.
Need assistance?
Get in touch with one of our success experts.
