Best Sailboat Rentals Near Fishers Island

Name: Sailing JOURNEY on the sound!
Rating: 5.0

Insurance provided by

Labor Day Weekend Boat Rentals

Our top sailboat rentals

$150+ /hour

Shelter Island Heights, NY

5.0 (22 bookings)

Sailing JOURNEY on the sound!

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$750+ /hour

Sag Harbor, NY

5.0 (30 bookings)

41' Beautiful sailing catamaran

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 12 passengers

$331+ /hour

Greenport, NY

Sail on "Surprise", a beautiful and comfortable 50' wooden ketch

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$1,325+ /hour

Warwick, RI

5.0 (1 booking)

⚓ Luxury Lagoon 620 Catamaran – Day Charters in Rhode Island

3 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 12 passengers

$182+ /hour

Newport, RI

5.0 (4 bookings)

Newport RI Sailing, sightseeing and swimming

2 - 4 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$725+ /hour

Greenport, NY

5.0 (2 bookings)

72-ft Traditional Schooner - Up to 20+ guests!

2 - 6 hours Captained

Up to 32 passengers

$359+ /hour

Sag Harbor, NY

Sailing Charter – Explore the Hamptons from Sag Harbor

4 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$1,200+ /hour

Sag Harbor, NY

A Coast Guard Certified Classic Mahogany Trimaran

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 26 passengers

$200+ /hour

Newport, RI

5.0 (10 bookings)

Sail on Mariah- Catalina 320

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$1,063+ /hour

Sag Harbor, NY

5.0 (38 bookings)

62' sailing cat: bachelorette, sandbar, sunsets

3 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 12 passengers

$130+ /hour

Old Saybrook, CT

5.0 (5 bookings)

30' Nonsuch Classic for Sail in Old Saybrook, CT!

4 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$198+ /hour

Flanders, NY

5.0 (5 bookings)

34' Gemini 2010 Catamaran Long Island

Sag Harbor, NY

Classic Beauty - 46 foot Bluewater Cruiser

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$200+ /hour

Newport, RI

4.9 (34 bookings)

Sound Mariner Charters- Catalina 320 Mariah

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

$1,280+ /hour

Sag Harbor, NY

5.0 (5 bookings)

Luxurious Sailing Schooner for Events up to 41 guests.

2 - 8 hours Captained

Up to 41 passengers

Rent a Catalina sloop in Westbrook, CT near me

$300+ /hour

Westbrook, CT

5.0 (8 bookings)

A Long Island Sound Sailing Experience!

2 - 3 hours Captained

Up to 6 passengers

Top sailboat rentals reviews in Fishers Island, NY

301,205

Customers Reviews

4.95

Avg. Rating

5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

We had an absolutely wonderful time on our boat trip with Captain Brian and Erin. From the moment we stepped on...

Jason

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

We had an amazing day with Captain Brian. Such a pleasure to out on the open seas with! He was an incredible host and...

rebecca

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

Sail on Mariah-...

Thanks Perrin for taking us out for a sunset cruise! We really enjoyed it!

Isabelle

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

We had a beautiful 3-hour boat trip. There were 9 of us and we were super comfortable and loved our afternoon. Brian...

Holly

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

Classic Beauty -...

Amazing day !
We booked a charter on Alan’s boat to celebrate my wife’s birthday. The experience was incredible ...

Colin

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

We had an awesome time ! Would definitely recommend

Christianne

Aug 2025
5/5 stars

Sail on Mariah-...

Very nice time on the water and a perfect activity for 4 of us. Capt Kenny was great and we look forward to another...

Drew

Jul 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

Brian was amazing and was very communicative about all the details leading up to the rental. We had an awesome time...

Beth

Jul 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

Brian is the consummate captain. Friendly, safe, knowledgeable. We used him for a sunset cruise to dinner on...

Michael

Jul 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

Brian was a great captain - so friendly and communicative! The boat was perfect for our group of 11 for a...

Gwendolyn

Jul 2025
5/5 stars

41' Beautiful...

The boat was beautiful and Brian was great. 10/10 recommend. Will definitely book with him again.

Elisabeth

Jul 2025
5/5 stars

⚓ Luxury Lagoon...

This was such a great experience. It worked out so well on such a short notice. I would definitely recommend and use...

Michelle

Jul 2025

How to rent a sailboat in Fishers Island?

Find the perfect boat

Enter your desired location and date to explore our fleet of sailboats.

Select a captain

Choose to drive yourself or select a USCG licensed captain.

Book with ease

Connect with your boat owner and complete your booking online.

Set sail

Enjoy your day on the water with friends and family!

Why Boatsetter?

As the global leader in peer-to-peer boat rentals, Boatsetter offers an easy, safe and accessible way to experience on-the-water adventure. With boat rentals in 600+ locations, finding a boat is easy and with the option to tap into the largest network of USCG licensed captains, boating experience is not required.

Get out on the water worry-free, knowing our insurance covers every boating trip

Choosing the right boat rental platform is essential to your peace of mind while on the water. That's why we've gone the extra mile to focus on safety through our exclusive partnership with GEICO Marine and BoatUS. As the first and only boat rental marketplace to offer insurance on every peer-to-peer rental, you are protected during all rentals with insurance coverage and on-water assistance through TowBoatUS.

Insurance provided by

Got questions?

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to rent a boat?

The cost to rent a boat depends on whether you are renting for a half-day or a full day, the boat features and the boat size can impact your boat rental price. Rental prices can range from $200 to $1,000 plus depending on the boat rental itself and the length of time of the rental.

How many people can fit on the boat rental?

The number of people who can fit on boat rental largely depends on the boat’s size and how many life jackets are on board. Currently the coast guard allows a maximum of 10-12 people on a Boatsetter boat rental.

How old do you have to be to rent a boat?

You must be 18 years old to rent a captained boat and 25 years old if you would like to rent a bareboat charter.

Do I need a boating license to rent a boat?

Boating license requirements vary from state to state. As a renter, you are responsible for understanding local state requirements.

How much does it cost to rent a boat for the day?

The cost of renting a boat for the day on average ranges from $200 to $1200. The cost to rent a boat varies depending on the size of the boat and the length of time that you will be using the boat.